Bernardes: Tennis Video Review Reduces Umpire Role, Risks 'Videogame' Future

The introduction of video review at Wimbledon marks a pivotal moment for tennis, a sport that has always sought a balance between tradition and innovation. Carlos Bernardes, a renowned former chair umpire who officiated three Grand Slam finals and the Olympic Games, offers his perspective on this evolving landscape.

Bernardes, who retired from the tour at the end of 2024, observed that Wimbledon's adoption of video review was an inevitable step, given that other Grand Slams and many tour events had already implemented it. He admits that during his career, such a tool would have made his job "much simpler," eliminating numerous discussions and the uncertainty surrounding the validity of players' protests.

However, the former umpire emphasizes how technology has significantly diminished the influence of officials in crucial decisions. While it offers greater protection by freeing them from the need to make "in or out" calls, it also removes them from the spotlight. Bernardes voices concern that, by removing the human element of error and emotion, the game "risks becoming a video game." He recalls an incident at the Olympics where a ball touch on a player's racket, neither seen nor heard, could have been clarified by VAR.

The relationship between players and umpires, once built on trust, has grown colder. Interruptions due to arguments have decreased, but the focus has shifted to explaining the use of VAR to the public. Looking to the future, Bernardes finds it difficult not to imagine the complete replacement of umpires, with decisions controlled entirely from outside the court, a concept even suggested by former tournament directors.

He concludes by stating that technology is now an integral part of tennis and life in general. The game is faster, with less tension, but the relationship between players and umpires has irreversibly changed. Much like in football, where attention shifts to VAR after a goal, technology now dominates in tennis. Bernardes states he "wouldn't bet against" the possible disappearance of the chair umpire.